Chamber of Commerce

      Casey's

      ( 78 Reviews )

      Casey's
      Order Pizza Delivery
      Claim Your Listing
      Claim Your Listing
      Listing Incorrect?
      Listing Incorrect?

      Hours

      Monday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Tuesday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Wednesday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Thursday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Friday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Saturday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Sunday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      CALL DIRECTIONS REVIEWS

      Chamber Rating

      3.9 - (78 reviews)
      42
      14
      7
      5
      10
      Read Our 78 Reviews

      Chamber Rating

      3.9 - (78 reviews)
      42
      14
      7
      5
      10
      › ‹
      • Emily

        Not really sure whats going on with my pizza or how it can be multiple different sizes if they werent pulled from other pizzas. I feel like for the price it better be able to compare to places nearby. For as much hype as the pizza here gets and my previous experiences with other Caseys I was a bit let down.
        Feb 10th, 2024

      • Erv Zaikis

        It's a gas station/convenience store.
        Jan 15th, 2024

      • Bo Robinson

        The manager Erica is absolutely amazing. Always brining a positive vibe and cheerful. Erica always goes above and beyond everytime i see her. Return customer for that alone.
        Nov 15th, 2023

      • Lindsey T


        Oct 15th, 2023

      • cuppy199

        I have been ordering from here for years with no problems. Always get the taco pizza. I picked it up and noticed when I got home there was no lettuce on it. There was barely any sauce on it was told they changed the sauce. I was just calling to tell them because maybe there was a mixup. Was told I would receive a free pizza the next time. I was like they didn't have to but ok I would take it. That's not what upset me or getting the pizza wrong didn't really upset me either. But then the manager calls me back and said she watched the video of them making it and they put the lettuce on pretty much saying I was lying. I offered to bring it back or send a picture. She said she seen the video. I said I would like to see the video because I know there is no lettuce on it. I know dorn well it was not on the video because there was NO lettuce on it. After being a customer since they opened and never once ever complained I won't be ordering a pizza or getting anything from that gas station again.I'm attaching a photo of the pizza you tell me if you see lettuce on it.
        Aug 10th, 2023

      Read Our 78 Reviews

      About
      Casey's

      Your Dyer, IN Casey's at 1502 Sheffield Ave has the best pizza delivery and pickup featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We've also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety of household essentials and groceries. When you're stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuels - Whatever you need, Casey's is here to help.

      Contact Info

      Products

      • Pizza
      • Fuel
      • Gas
      • Groceries
      • Coffee

      Services

      • Delivery

      Languages

      • English

      Specialities

      • Made-from-Scratch Pizza
      • Fresh Ingredients
      • Quality Fuel
      • Friendly Service

      Payment Methods

      • AMERICANEXPRESS
      • ANDROIDPAY
      • APPLEPAY
      • CASH
      • DINERSCLUB
      • DISCOVER
      • MASTERCARD
      • SAMSUNGPAY
      • VISA

      Questions & Answers

      Q What is the phone number for Casey's?

      A The phone number for Casey's is: (219) 250-6936.

      Q Where is Casey's located?

      A Casey's is located at 1502 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, Indiana 46311

      Q What is the internet address for Casey's?

      A The website (URL) for Casey's is: https://www.caseys.com/general-store/in-dyer/1502-sheffield-ave/2352?utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=yext&y_source=1_MTcyMDY5MzAtNTQ1LWxvY2F0aW9uLndlYnNpdGU%3D

      Q How big is Casey's?

      A Casey's employs approximately 20+ people.

      Q What days are Casey's open?

      A Casey's is open:
      Monday: 4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Tuesday: 4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Wednesday: 4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Thursday: 4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Friday: 4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Saturday: 4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Sunday: 4:00 AM - 10:00 PM

      Q How is Casey's rated?

      A Casey's has a 3.9 Star Rating from 78 reviewers.

      Hours

      Monday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Tuesday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Wednesday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Thursday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Friday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Saturday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Sunday:
      4:00 AM - 10:00 PM
      Nearby Casey Locations

      Ratings and Reviews
      Casey's

      Overall Rating

      Overall Rating
      ( 78 Reviews )
      42
      14
      7
      5
      10
      Write a Review

      Emily on Google

      image Not really sure whats going on with my pizza or how it can be multiple different sizes if they werent pulled from other pizzas. I feel like for the price it better be able to compare to places nearby. For as much hype as the pizza here gets and my previous experiences with other Caseys I was a bit let down.

      Erv Zaikis on Google

      image It's a gas station/convenience store.

      Bo Robinson on Google

      image The manager Erica is absolutely amazing. Always brining a positive vibe and cheerful. Erica always goes above and beyond everytime i see her. Return customer for that alone.

      Lindsey T on Google

      image

      cuppy199 on Google

      image I have been ordering from here for years with no problems. Always get the taco pizza. I picked it up and noticed when I got home there was no lettuce on it. There was barely any sauce on it was told they changed the sauce. I was just calling to tell them because maybe there was a mixup. Was told I would receive a free pizza the next time. I was like they didn't have to but ok I would take it. That's not what upset me or getting the pizza wrong didn't really upset me either. But then the manager calls me back and said she watched the video of them making it and they put the lettuce on pretty much saying I was lying. I offered to bring it back or send a picture. She said she seen the video. I said I would like to see the video because I know there is no lettuce on it. I know dorn well it was not on the video because there was NO lettuce on it. After being a customer since they opened and never once ever complained I won't be ordering a pizza or getting anything from that gas station again.I'm attaching a photo of the pizza you tell me if you see lettuce on it.

      Business Response on Google Jul 21st, 2023
      This does not represent Casey's and our commitment to our community. We will share your feedback with our Dyer team. We'd appreciate a chance to speak with you directly. Please reach out to us at https://www.caseys.com/contact
      Load More Reviews

      Overall Rating

      Overall Rating
      ( 78 Reviews )
      42
      14
      7
      5
      10

      Write a Review

      RATING:
      Create 1 Star Review Create 2 Star Review Create 3 Star Review Create 4 Star Review Create 5 Star Review
      Submit

      Pizza Delivery Near Me in Dyer, IN

      Beggar's Pizza
      3344 Sheffield Ave
      Dyer, IN 46311
      219-322-4448
      ( 576 Reviews )
      State Line Pizza Dyer
      183 Matteson St
      Dyer, IN 46311
      219-865-2922
      ( 179 Reviews )
      Doreen™s Pizzeria
      726 Joliet Street,
      Dyer, IN 46311
      (219) 865-9988
      ( 217 Reviews )

      START DRIVING

      ONLINE LEADS TODAY!

      Add Your Business
      ChamberofCommerce.com
      Loading