Pie Insurance

Awful experience. Was audited for my premium, which is standard practice in the industry, and told by an employee that she would get the necessary info from my accountant. Months later I received a nasty email saying my premium was going up. I asked why and was told I was deemed "non-compliant" on the audit. When I called the company, I would wait on hold for upwards of 20 minutes before being sent to voicemail. This happened 5 times. So to summarize, Pie will lie to you, jack up premium, then not speak with you. Look elsewhere for insurance.
Feb 8th, 2024

Dec 30th, 2023

I am not sure where those reviews are coming from, but I have nothing nothing but good things to say about PIE. The people are kind, and knowledge and the follow up is very quickly and what more do you want from a workman's comp insurer. Besides I have found them to be about 25% less than other carriers.
Oct 22nd, 2023

These guys are terrible. ADP payroll convinced us to go with PIE for our workers comp insurance and said all fees would be automatically taken out every week. They don't tell you that you will be audited and they will add tons of fees onto the policy calling them audit fees. The Audit fees were more than the actual workers compensation premiums we paid for the whole year. I would avoid these guys unless you like surprises.
Aug 3rd, 2023

What a P.O.S. Company! Been with this company for 8 years, never spoke to a human, never missed a payment and never filed a claim. After them making $50,000.00 from our company, they canceled our Workers Comp. "We don't appeal to their appetite" was the exact words they used. Their appetite was strong getting that $50,000.00! If you use this company after reading these reviews, your going to get what you deserve.
Jul 20th, 2023