Gargano Pasta & Italian Market
Permanently Closed
-
75 Main St
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Chamber Rating
-
C. M.
Food can be good but the portions tend to be small & prices are expensive. Products are also expensive. Coffee & croissant were solid. The fried pasta is neither kitschy nor tasty. Replace it with a solid side not a cheap filler. Pizza was meh. Cocktails actually looked pretty good. I was NOT impressed with the owners or the management. They are not very nice or good to their staff which is a big disappointment & a deal breaker for me. Hard pass.
Aug 4th, 2023 -
Britney Evarts
I was very excited to try this place. I had a gift card and I work locally and saw they delivered and was looking forward to ordering lunch. The delivery service they use had no option to use a gift card and when I called and asked if I was missing something the woman who answered told me that others have had this issue, she knows theres a way to do it, but she doesnt know and cant help me. Very poor customer service given the prices of the food. I decided to go there myself and order in person anyway as the menu looked great. When I got back to my office (5 minutes away) my sandwiches were soggy and basic. I spent $40 for poor customer service and low quality food for that price. Looks good on paper but not worth the cost.
Jul 18th, 2023 -
Steven Webb
No problems here. Large restaurant in a strip mall. Great flavourful pizza, great coffee selection. WCs downstairs are a bit odd, small, but they are clean. Prices are about right for delicious pizza.
Jun 25th, 2023 -
Laten
The pizza is the best! Im from New Haven and I can say this is a close match. The roasted peppers, homemade meatballs, sausage and basil was an amazing combination. I loved the traditional pizzas I will definitely go back. Well done Garganos!!!
Jun 23rd, 2023 -
juliana tryon
Absolutely top notch pizza and pasta. Great lunch spot.
Jun 19th, 2023
Contact Info
Questions & Answers
Q Where is Gargano Pasta & Italian Market located?
A Gargano Pasta & Italian Market is located at 75 Main St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
Q How is Gargano Pasta & Italian Market rated?
A Gargano Pasta & Italian Market has a 4.2 Star Rating from 61 reviewers.
Related Categories
Ratings and Reviews
Gargano Pasta & Italian Market
Overall Rating
Overall Rating
( 61 Reviews )C. M. on Google
Food can be good but the portions tend to be small & prices are expensive. Products are also expensive. Coffee & croissant were solid. The fried pasta is neither kitschy nor tasty. Replace it with a solid side not a cheap filler. Pizza was meh. Cocktails actually looked pretty good.
I was NOT impressed with the owners or the management. They are not very nice or good to their staff which is a big disappointment & a deal breaker for me. Hard pass.
Britney Evarts on Google
I was very excited to try this place. I had a gift card and I work locally and saw they delivered and was looking forward to ordering lunch. The delivery service they use had no option to use a gift card and when I called and asked if I was missing something the woman who answered told me that others have had this issue, she knows theres a way to do it, but she doesnt know and cant help me. Very poor customer service given the prices of the food. I decided to go there myself and order in person anyway as the menu looked great. When I got back to my office (5 minutes away) my sandwiches were soggy and basic. I spent $40 for poor customer service and low quality food for that price. Looks good on paper but not worth the cost.
Steven Webb on Google
No problems here. Large restaurant in a strip mall. Great flavourful pizza, great coffee selection. WCs downstairs are a bit odd, small, but they are clean. Prices are about right for delicious pizza.
Laten on Google
The pizza is the best! Im from New Haven and I can say this is a close match. The roasted peppers, homemade meatballs, sausage and basil was an amazing combination. I loved the traditional pizzas
I will definitely go back. Well done Garganos!!!
juliana tryon on Google
Absolutely top notch pizza and pasta. Great lunch spot.
Overall Rating
Overall Rating
( 61 Reviews )Write a Review
Restaurant Near Me in Old Saybrook, CT
Svec Remodeling LLC
Old Saybrook, CT
(860) 575-5933 ( 0 Reviews )
Back Porch Restaurant
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
860-510-0282 ( 392 Reviews )
Penny Lane Pub
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
860-388-9646 ( 784 Reviews )
Dock & Dine Restaurant
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
(860) 388-4665 ( 4 Reviews )
Aspen Restaurant
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
860-395-5888 ( 343 Reviews )
Middlesex Tree
Old Saybrook, CT
(860) 339-5605 ( 22 Reviews )
Paperback Cafe
Old Saybrook, CT 06475
860-388-9718 ( 739 Reviews )
Fraser Contracting
Old Saybrook, CT
(860) 388-2093 ( 0 Reviews )