Gargano Pasta & Italian Market

Permanently Closed

Chamber Rating

4.2 - (61 reviews)
43
4
4
4
6
Read Our 61 Reviews

Chamber Rating

4.2 - (61 reviews)
43
4
4
4
6
  • C. M.

    Food can be good but the portions tend to be small & prices are expensive. Products are also expensive. Coffee & croissant were solid. The fried pasta is neither kitschy nor tasty. Replace it with a solid side not a cheap filler. Pizza was meh. Cocktails actually looked pretty good. I was NOT impressed with the owners or the management. They are not very nice or good to their staff which is a big disappointment & a deal breaker for me. Hard pass.
    Aug 4th, 2023

  • Britney Evarts

    I was very excited to try this place. I had a gift card and I work locally and saw they delivered and was looking forward to ordering lunch. The delivery service they use had no option to use a gift card and when I called and asked if I was missing something the woman who answered told me that others have had this issue, she knows theres a way to do it, but she doesnt know and cant help me. Very poor customer service given the prices of the food. I decided to go there myself and order in person anyway as the menu looked great. When I got back to my office (5 minutes away) my sandwiches were soggy and basic. I spent $40 for poor customer service and low quality food for that price. Looks good on paper but not worth the cost.
    Jul 18th, 2023

  • Steven Webb

    No problems here. Large restaurant in a strip mall. Great flavourful pizza, great coffee selection. WCs downstairs are a bit odd, small, but they are clean. Prices are about right for delicious pizza.
    Jun 25th, 2023

  • Laten

    The pizza is the best! Im from New Haven and I can say this is a close match. The roasted peppers, homemade meatballs, sausage and basil was an amazing combination. I loved the traditional pizzas I will definitely go back. Well done Garganos!!!
    Jun 23rd, 2023

  • juliana tryon

    Absolutely top notch pizza and pasta. Great lunch spot.
    Jun 19th, 2023

Read Our 61 Reviews

About
Gargano Pasta & Italian Market

Gargano Pasta & Italian Market is located at 75 Main St in Old Saybrook, Connecticut 06475. Gargano Pasta & Italian Market can be contacted via phone at for pricing, hours and directions.

Contact Info

    Questions & Answers

    Q Where is Gargano Pasta & Italian Market located?

    A Gargano Pasta & Italian Market is located at 75 Main St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475


    Q How is Gargano Pasta & Italian Market rated?

    A Gargano Pasta & Italian Market has a 4.2 Star Rating from 61 reviewers.

    Ratings and Reviews
    Gargano Pasta & Italian Market

    Overall Rating

    Overall Rating
    ( 61 Reviews )
    43
    4
    4
    4
    6
    Write a Review

    C. M. on Google

    image Food can be good but the portions tend to be small & prices are expensive. Products are also expensive. Coffee & croissant were solid. The fried pasta is neither kitschy nor tasty. Replace it with a solid side not a cheap filler. Pizza was meh. Cocktails actually looked pretty good.
    I was NOT impressed with the owners or the management. They are not very nice or good to their staff which is a big disappointment & a deal breaker for me. Hard pass.


    Britney Evarts on Google

    image I was very excited to try this place. I had a gift card and I work locally and saw they delivered and was looking forward to ordering lunch. The delivery service they use had no option to use a gift card and when I called and asked if I was missing something the woman who answered told me that others have had this issue, she knows theres a way to do it, but she doesnt know and cant help me. Very poor customer service given the prices of the food. I decided to go there myself and order in person anyway as the menu looked great. When I got back to my office (5 minutes away) my sandwiches were soggy and basic. I spent $40 for poor customer service and low quality food for that price. Looks good on paper but not worth the cost.


    Steven Webb on Google

    image No problems here. Large restaurant in a strip mall. Great flavourful pizza, great coffee selection. WCs downstairs are a bit odd, small, but they are clean. Prices are about right for delicious pizza.


    Laten on Google

    image The pizza is the best! Im from New Haven and I can say this is a close match. The roasted peppers, homemade meatballs, sausage and basil was an amazing combination. I loved the traditional pizzas
    I will definitely go back. Well done Garganos!!!


    juliana tryon on Google

    image Absolutely top notch pizza and pasta. Great lunch spot.


    Load More Reviews

    Overall Rating

    Overall Rating
    ( 61 Reviews )
    43
    4
    4
    4
    6

    Write a Review

    RATING:
    Create 1 Star Review Create 2 Star Review Create 3 Star Review Create 4 Star Review Create 5 Star Review

    Restaurant Near Me in Old Saybrook, CT

    Svec Remodeling LLC

    Old Saybrook, CT
    (860) 575-5933
    ( 0 Reviews )
    Back Porch Restaurant
    142 Ferry Rd
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    860-510-0282
    ( 392 Reviews )
    Penny Lane Pub
    150 Main St
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    860-388-9646
    ( 784 Reviews )
    Dock & Dine Restaurant
    145 College St
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    (860) 388-4665
    ( 4 Reviews )
    Aspen Restaurant
    2 Main St
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    860-395-5888
    ( 343 Reviews )
    Middlesex Tree

    Old Saybrook, CT
    (860) 339-5605
    ( 22 Reviews )
    Paperback Cafe
    210 Main St #8
    Old Saybrook, CT 06475
    860-388-9718
    ( 739 Reviews )
    Fraser Contracting

    Old Saybrook, CT
    (860) 388-2093
    ( 0 Reviews )

    START DRIVING

    ONLINE LEADS TODAY!

    ChamberofCommerce.com
    Loading