Hours

Friday:
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday:
8:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Sunday:
Closed
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
Closed
Wednesday:
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Thursday:
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM

Chamber Rating

4.3 - (48 reviews)
32
7
3
1
5
Read Our 48 Reviews

Chamber Rating

4.3 - (48 reviews)
32
7
3
1
5
  • Hans W.

    Pretty disappointed. I ordered a 9" birthday cake. It looked really good. Decorated nicely and iced neatly etc... Problem: the icing was like eating a mouthful of Crisco. It wasn't sweet at all. I don't need an overly sweet icing but this was terrible. The whole cake was incredibly bland. I appreciated the fact she was able to take my order for a birthday cake needed the next day but this was a massive let down. At $50 for the cake, never again.
    Dec 26th, 2023

  • Justin Clemens

    This lady is rude beyond belief. Just look at her reviews and her replies to those reviews. Save your money and your time by going to a different place.
    Dec 11th, 2023

  • Mark Freeman

    My girlfriend and I wanted to support a local business and this looked like a cute place. First thing we noticed walking in was the extremely high prices. Granted the sweets looked good but 4 dollars for a cinnamon roll, over 40 dollars for a single pie, 30 dollars for 12 cookies.. we just ordered 1 vanilla chai drink to share to see the quality before digging deeper in our pockets. 7 dollars for a drink that tasted pretty bland compared to the other two places we regularly go to. Also, the lady just seemed.. not happy. Wasn't welcoming at all. There was no greeting like a hi! How are you?.. she acted annoyed that we wanted to add white chocolate and brown sugar cinnamon to our drink..ill say that she was not Rude, but she wasn't at all happy to make our drink for us. I had high hopes for the place, but we won't be back. Especially after looking at other reviews and seeing that she was rude with other customers that had complaints. If you run a business. You should always try to make things right, not be miserable and tell them to not come back. If the lady even smiled at us, it would've made the whole experience a tiny bit better..but she couldn't even do that.
    Nov 14th, 2023

  • Michael Mertz

    Great little bakery with some very good pastry selections. Got the bear claw and the cinnamon roll.
    Oct 8th, 2023

  • M Thoma

    Delicious torte!
    Aug 2nd, 2023

Read Our 48 Reviews

About
Proper Pastry

Proper Pastry is located at 139 N Main St in Roanoke, Indiana 46783. Proper Pastry can be contacted via phone at 260-413-5203 for pricing, hours and directions.

Contact Info

  •   260-413-5203

Questions & Answers

Q What is the phone number for Proper Pastry?

A The phone number for Proper Pastry is: 260-413-5203.


Q Where is Proper Pastry located?

A Proper Pastry is located at 139 N Main St, Roanoke, IN 46783


Q What is the internet address for Proper Pastry?

A The website (URL) for Proper Pastry is: http://www.properpastry.com/


Q What days are Proper Pastry open?

A Proper Pastry is open:
Friday: 8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday: 8:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Thursday: 8:00 AM - 4:00 PM


Q How is Proper Pastry rated?

A Proper Pastry has a 4.3 Star Rating from 48 reviewers.

Hours

Friday:
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday:
8:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Sunday:
Closed
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
Closed
Wednesday:
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Thursday:
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM

Ratings and Reviews
Proper Pastry

Overall Rating

Overall Rating
( 48 Reviews )
32
7
3
1
5
Write a Review

Hans W. on Google

image Pretty disappointed. I ordered a 9" birthday cake. It looked really good. Decorated nicely and iced neatly etc... Problem: the icing was like eating a mouthful of Crisco. It wasn't sweet at all. I don't need an overly sweet icing but this was terrible. The whole cake was incredibly bland.
I appreciated the fact she was able to take my order for a birthday cake needed the next day but this was a massive let down. At $50 for the cake, never again.


Justin Clemens on Google

image This lady is rude beyond belief. Just look at her reviews and her replies to those reviews. Save your money and your time by going to a different place.


Mark Freeman on Google

image My girlfriend and I wanted to support a local business and this looked like a cute place. First thing we noticed walking in was the extremely high prices. Granted the sweets looked good but 4 dollars for a cinnamon roll, over 40 dollars for a single pie, 30 dollars for 12 cookies.. we just ordered 1 vanilla chai drink to share to see the quality before digging deeper in our pockets. 7 dollars for a drink that tasted pretty bland compared to the other two places we regularly go to. Also, the lady just seemed.. not happy. Wasn't welcoming at all. There was no greeting like a hi! How are you?.. she acted annoyed that we wanted to add white chocolate and brown sugar cinnamon to our drink..ill say that she was not Rude, but she wasn't at all happy to make our drink for us. I had high hopes for the place, but we won't be back. Especially after looking at other reviews and seeing that she was rude with other customers that had complaints. If you run a business. You should always try to make things right, not be miserable and tell them to not come back.
If the lady even smiled at us, it would've made the whole experience a tiny bit better..but she couldn't even do that.

Business Response on Google Dec 7th, 2023
I would disregard this review. This couple asked for 3 things that were not on the menu. I gladly made it for them but had to run all over my store for the ingredients. I'm sorry you didn't care for me but I think that's your problem. Besides waiting on people I also take care of special orders on Saturdays so I am distracted. Also, my prices are higher than most bakeries because I use organic, local, and non GMO ingredients. Maybe if you paid more attention to the pastries than my face you would have noticed that.

Michael Mertz on Google

image Great little bakery with some very good pastry selections. Got the bear claw and the cinnamon roll.


M Thoma on Google

image Delicious torte!


Load More Reviews

Overall Rating

Overall Rating
( 48 Reviews )
32
7
3
1
5

Write a Review

RATING:
Create 1 Star Review Create 2 Star Review Create 3 Star Review Create 4 Star Review Create 5 Star Review

Bakery Near Me in Roanoke, IN

Tim Hortons
12200 Lafayette Center Rd
Roanoke, Indiana 46783
260-673-2617
( 28 Reviews )
Grandma Sue's Pies & More
287 N Main St
Roanoke, IN 46783
(260) 445-6081
( 16 Reviews )

START DRIVING

ONLINE LEADS TODAY!

ChamberofCommerce.com
Loading