The Cricket Club

All around wonderful experience. Service was outstanding, food was incredible, and atmosphere was upbeat and energizing. My wife swears by the loaded potato muffins and every table in our view ordered them and raved. I enjoyed the oyster stew as well. For the main, I wife loved the gumbo as I did I with some leftovers. It's a great vegan and gluten free option. It has a little spicy, but not too much. For my main, I had a special filet and lobster mashed potatoes. OH MY, this was incredible!!! Drink menu was a good and I really enjoyed the entertainment, Gordan Vincent a Cape May regular. Meal was slightly on the expensive side, but not crazy overpriced. Dietary restrictions: LOTS of gluten free options.
Apr 6th, 2024

15Mar- As we were big fans of the previous occupant, The Merion Inn, while in town we decided to take a chance and try this new place. Called for an early dinner and greeted by a very friendly and humorous gentleman who set us up with a table just around the corner from the bar w/live music. Opened with wine and of course, a Bloody Mary. Excellent choices and the Bloody was mixed in house (no pre-mix), Big plus. It was a bit light with the add ons but made up for it in flavor. It was extra spicy and delicious. Highly recommended. Our entries included scallops with whipped sweet potatoes and green beans. I had the special, Halibut w/couscous in a cream sauce. We can't say enough about our meals. Both were absolutely outstanding as was the service. Big props to Kelly She helped make our dinner fun and after our long drive, it was a pleasure. We finished with their own cinnamon ice cream over apple cobbler. Again, excellent. A bit pricey but, worth every penny. Remembering you are a stone's throw from Cape Mays pristine beaches. Great service, great meal, great atmosphere. We will absolutely return. 5 Solid Stars Highly recommended
Mar 17th, 2024

Best onion soup in Cape May! Scallops were excellent as well as the short rib. My only comment is the side dishes are not original. String beans and mashed potatoes I can do at home lol. Give me something I cant make in my Own home. Great service and staff.
Mar 10th, 2024

Mar 7th, 2024

Im giving 4 stars only because we didnt eat here but what I saw being served looked so good I was wishing we were hungry. We were in town on a weekend mid-February and stopped in late afternoon. We sat at the bar and had a couple drinks. They were very good and the bartenders were personable and attentive. The atmosphere was warm and welcoming. Bathrooms were clean. We walked from the hotel so I cant comment on parking but Cape May is pretty walkable. If Im ever in Cape May again I would come back here to try the food.
Feb 21st, 2024