Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West, New York

My second visit to Emmy Squared (since they debuted in Williamsburg as a stand-alone pizzeria) and I feared that the conversion to a chain would have destroyed quality. Fortunately, NOT. Not only were the pizzas beyond delicious (Colony, Margherita & Vodka), but equally importantly, the staff were super pleasant & kind. Portions were huge but I couldn't help scarfing down a whole pizza in one sitting ... cos t'was *that* good! As a plus, this location was not packed to the gills on a friday night (unlike the rest of the locations) so we got seated immediately without reservations. Decor is en pointe with a dark minimalist interior. The restrooms were super clean which is indicative of staff morale - shows they take pride in their workplace. Drinks (beers and the Warwick Valley Apple Cider) were delish and moderately priced as well. Highly recommended
Mar 9th, 2024

Have been to other locations and love the food. Unfortunately, this location is not up to par. Waited 15 minutes to place our order and 30 minutes for our drinks. The chicken parm sandwich is basically a chick-fil-a sandwich with sauce and a basil leaf. Was really hoping it would be better, but recommend you dont waste the time or money.
Mar 7th, 2024

Mar 4th, 2024

I can't review for service or atmosphere though my brother says it's great I have not been in but will in th future. This is all about the pizza, specifically the pineapple pizza which I was so angry at him for getting because it just isn't good... Except here. I was hungry so I ate what was available and it was love at first bite and this is now my go-to place.
Feb 23rd, 2024

Amazing food and amazing service at this location came in late last night and the manager ensured. We had an awesome experience would definitely recommend.
Feb 9th, 2024