Indiana Cake Shop

Margo is the best!

We ordered a custom tiered cake for our sons 5th birthday. The staff were so kind and they did a wonderful job. 5 Thank you Hart Bakery.

They made a wonderful cake, and the service was great!

On my husbands google account, but I have got to say I have nothing but AMAZING words about this place. From their coffee to the people that work there. Yummy cookies and ... more

Spoke to the owner, she was very sweet and friendly. I love the Gurt but do wish it was a little bit cheaper so i can buy it more often.

I love frozen yogurt so much, so I hate that this is the only place to get it in Columbus. The hours are so inconsistent and its very frustrating. Just yesterday I walked ... more

The funnel cake was delicious but overpriced.

Highly Recommend When we first ordered from here it was just to support a local business, but we have had so many great experiences that going forward we will order all ... more

This place is absolutely adorable and the owner is so bubbly and sweet. Very kind. Offered samples. Would absolutely go there any time we need anything. Omg had to come b ... more

Tanya, thank you for the beautiful wedding cake you made for my daughters wedding. As usual, it was absolutely delicious. You are the best and will always be the best!

This specific location is horrendous in terms of management. They do not take care of their employees or treat them with basic respect at all. They are one of the few rem ... more

These people are totally amazing!!!!!!

We ordered 2 yogurts, one not even filled to the top of the cup & it was $20. Absolutely insane!

Called for a last minute birthday cake. All I heard was "no problem". Cake looks and tastes amazing. Highly recommend

I believe this is the number 1 bakery in the city, she even has you covered if you are vegan. Mama P does custom cakes and was warm and friendly over the phone. She made ... more

Employees are rude. You do not feel like they want you there. Very rude and unprofessional attitudes. We left without ordering and wont be returning.

Pretty disappointed. I paid $135 for the basic unicorn cake, that feeds 10-12 people. inaccurate . Fed more like 6 people. It was pretty and tasted okay, but it was hig ... more

My fianc and I have been on the looking for someone to do our wedding cake for us for about a year now, I personally have very high expectations since my parents previous ... more

Prices are going up faster than CPI. Otherwise, it's probably the best donut in town.

Good if you are looking for donuts not too sweet.

I got my wedding cake and cupcakes from here! From the beginning I got to sit down with Sarah and explain how I wanted my cake to look. She was super great to work with a ... more

10 out of Five I stopped in to look/smell and the woman working chatted me up, gave me a sample cookie and then a box of cookies More proof that New Albany is one of ... more

Emily did an excellent job with our wedding cake! She designed the cake to match the lace appliqu on my wedding dress and it was so beautiful! We were very impressed. She ... more

I've only had the cookies and donuts from here, they were absolutely delicious, I highly recommend trying their baked goods! The menu overall is impressive and fairly pr ... more

All the dessert here is excellent! I don't even have any dietary restrictions but I choose here over other places just because it tastes so good :) I'm a big fan of the f ... more

Easy to order and speedy delivery!

Machines take forever to win on.

Great staff. Great Ice cream. Great atmosphere!

Ordered wedding cake in January of 2020. Prepaid for cake. Due to pandemic, had to change size of cake for our June 2020 wedding. Was told to come back after the weddi ... more

Great place for cakes. Was passing through from fort wayne and had to stop! Well worth it!

Ohh my cakes made us a beautiful wedding cake! They coordinated with our florist to decorate, and the day-of, our cake arrived at the venue and was decorated on site. The ... more

Amazing food and service! I will eat here again and again

I cannot share enough good things about our wedding cake! First of all there was a last-minute accommodation made for me, which I was so thankful for. They were professio ... more

Great cakes with unlimited options to customize! It is definitely good for all occasions. I am thinking of buying one for my son for his birthday.

The way the management treats homeless people is disgusting and sickening. This homeless woman came in to buy some cookies and they immediately asked her to leave even th ... more

Kelcy always knocks it out of the park for our cakes! My daughter is allergic to dairy and eggs and Kelcy always makes sure she has a cake she can eat in her birthday!

Great ice cream. Large variety of flavors and pet friendly for pup cups

What a wonderful welcome on this peculiar day of solar eclipse. We live in Cincinnati and made a stop at the bakery for coffee and glazed donuts.

Fun, girly atmosphere. Food was delicious.

As always in one word...YUMMY! Kim's Bakery Team did an amazing job on my birthday cake and cupcakes. Thanks for helping make my special day even more memorable. The cake ... more

Best ice cream

I love the donut bank and so does my granddaughter

Amateur craftsmanship was very disappointing, the 5 stars & supposedly amazing pictures were very misleading. It looks like it was drawn on by an elementary school studen ... more

Love this place. Always has fresh dough nuts, and the best customer service.

Donuts are always good from donut bank. Service was a bit slow. But they were friendly. And they had the cutest t-shirts.